Corporate

Dissolving Corporate Deadlock: Summary of Judicial Procedures for Company Dissolution Actions

6 MIN READ
ABSTRACT

With the development of company registration, many companies face deadlock situations. This article summarizes the procedural aspects of company dissolution litigation, covering standing, statutory grounds, jurisdiction, evidence preservation, and practical strategies.

I. Standing to Sue

1. Plaintiffs: Shareholders Holding 10%+ Voting Rights

The court determines shareholder qualification based on registered shareholder records. Nominal shareholders (隐名股东) not registered on shareholder registers generally cannot directly sue for dissolution. They must first obtain judicial confirmation of their shareholder status through separate proceedings.

2. Defendants: The Company

The company dissolution action is a change action (变更之诉) against the company. Other shareholders may be joined as third parties.

3. Third Parties: Other Shareholders

The court may notify other shareholders as third parties, particularly given the mediation requirements under the司法解释.

II. Statutory Grounds for Dissolution

Under司法解释(二) Article 1 and Company Law Article 182, courts may order dissolution when:

  • Company business management suffers serious difficulties
  • Continued existence would cause significant loss to shareholders
  • Deadlock from shareholder disputes cannot be resolved
  • Other remedies have failed

1. Business Management Difficulties

Courts examine whether the governance structure (shareholder/director deadlock) has completely lost function.

2. Exhaustion of Other Remedies

Courts conduct formal review of whether other remedies were attempted. Shareholders should demonstrate in pleadings and evidence that reasonable alternative methods were exhausted.

III. Jurisdiction

1. Territorial Jurisdiction

Company dissolution cases are heard by the people’s court at the company’s domicile. Domicile means the primary place of business; if unclear, the registered location.

2. Level Jurisdiction

  • Companies registered with county/city/district authorities: Basic people’s courts
  • Companies registered with regional/municipal authorities or above: Intermediate people’s courts

IV. Evidence Preservation

Under司法解释(二) Article 3, shareholders may apply for property or evidence preservation by providing security and demonstrating necessity.

1. Purpose of Preservation

Preservation serves:

  • Protecting plaintiff interests from asset transfer during proceedings
  • Facilitating potential mandatory liquidation post-dissolution

2. Scope Determination

Courts generally defer to applicant-proposed amounts, considering factors including the applicant’s recoverable share, security capacity, and normal business operations.

4dfac6c22f20399c7b22b6ec5fbbadfc

RESEARCH TEAM

JIAO Chenglong Senior Partner

Jiao Chenglong is a Senior Partner and Executive Director at Long An (Qingdao) Law Firm. His professional roles include Executive Director of the Lawyers Association of Shinan District in Qingdao, Director of the Education, Training and Young Lawyer Development Committee of the Shinan District Lawyers Association, a member of the Company Law Committee and Bankruptcy and Liquidation Committee of Beijing Long An Law Firm, an Outstanding Young Lawyer of Qingdao, a specially appointed "volunteer law enforcement consultant" for the Shinan District Administrative Approval Bureau of Qingdao, and a part-time graduate student practical supervisor at the Law School of Qingdao University of Science and Technology. His practice areas are corporate legal counsel, equity and corporate governance, mergers and acquisitions, and construction engineering. He currently serves as a standing legal counsel for dozens of companies including China Energy Conservation (Jimo) Environmental Protection Energy Co., Ltd., Guomeng Wenchuang (Shandong) Development Group Co., Ltd., and Qingdao Wenjin Construction Group Co., Ltd. Tel: 18663969911 Email: jiaochenglong@longanlaw.com

WANG Di Attorney

Wang Di specializes in civil and commercial dispute resolution and government and corporate standing legal counsel services. She excels in handling litigation cases involving contract disputes, corporate equity disputes, labor and personnel dispute resolution, trademark infringement, and bill pursuit rights disputes. Tel: 13121629955 Email: wangdi@longanlaw.com